6 Columbus Central Park Hotel

The room was clean and comfortable. Decor and lighting are dark. Excellent desk staff. However, the photos of the rooftop terrace are misleading. The terrace is just a small deck with a limited view.

Unfortunately when we arrived we were quite disappointed with the standard of this hotel. It looked different to the pictures, the hallways felt dark and dingy, the floors were not particularly clean and there was used glassware left on the floor in the hallway to our room. Even small things like wonky room signs were offputting. The room itself was quite small with limited storage. The room wasn't perfectly clean, for example with dust on the bedside tables. On a positive note, the bed was clean and comfortable, the bathroom had nice decor but it still felt very dark with an average sized mirror. The shower handle fell off when we tried to use it for the first time, but the water pressure was good. The walls are also quite thin as we could very clearly hear a family in a nearby room who were very loud with young children, it sounded like they were right behind the door. We would have likely happily stayed in the property for half the price, but our stay (although it was over the New Year period) was not cheap so we expected a lot more from it. Thankfully the receptionist was very kind and supportive and helped us with cancelling the remainder of our stay after 1 night when we moved hotels.

The room was comfortable and a good size. It was wonderful to be able to make the room an icebox, the way I like it to sleep. The room was clean as well. Really appreciated the complimentary bottle of water. However, the amenities are sparse—I’ve stayed at this property in the past and there used to be a vanity kit (qtips/cotton balls) and they no longer had those, there was only one bathrobe, one garbage can, they don’t have the travel sized toiletries (this was a problem because the pump on the lotion was broken), only one bar of soap. The room is not functional for people under 6’ tall—I couldn’t see into the bathroom mirror, and the shower handle was too high up. The overhead light didn’t work and there was a hole in the comforter cover. Since we were only staying one night it wasn’t a big deal but the room was expensive for what we got. I think we had a king deluxe room.

Lovely old-style NYC hotel. Easy walk to Metropolitan Opera. Bellhops and front desk are open at all times, and the staff couldn’t be friendlier and more accommodating. The hotel has a Japanese Sushi restaurant that is attached on the lobby floor. We had a quick dinner there which was delicious. The bedroom, reminiscent of Art Deco interiors, sported a grand king-size bed with European style bedding. We had a good night’s sleep and the room service breakfast was excellent. Definitely recommended.

Excellent hotel with an unbeatable location. Stayed in a suite this time. Room was spacious, clean, and comfortaboe. Good price for the size of the room and central location. Staff were courteous and helpful. Restaurant serves amazing Japanese food for lunch and dinner and good, standard breafast. Highly recommend this hotel.

The room was clean and comfortable. Decor and lighting are dark. Excellent desk staff. However, the photos of the rooftop terrace are misleading. The terrace is just a small deck with a limited view.